top of page

Shedding Light on Dark Patterns: Transforming User Experiences


DesignImpulse - Shedding Light on Dark Patterns: Transforming User Experiences

A truly great user experience is built on transparency, not on the shadows of dark patterns.

In the ever-evolving digital landscape, user experience (UX) plays a pivotal role in shaping customer satisfaction and loyalty. However, the use of dark patterns has become an unethical practice that can undermine the very essence of positive user experiences. This article delves into the history of dark patterns, explores their various types, and discusses how companies can adopt ethical practices to improve UX. Additionally, we'll delve into how a robust UX process and the concept of UX maturity can contribute to eradicating dark patterns.


Dark patterns are deceptive user interfaces that benefit an online service by leading users into making decisions they might not otherwise make. The term “dark patterns” was coined by Harry Brignull, a user experience (UX) designer, in 2010. These patterns often exploit cognitive biases and employ tactics such as false urgency, forced actions, hidden costs, etc. They can range from overtly noticeable tricks to more subtle methods that users may not immediately recognize.

Recent studies have shed light on the prevalence of dark patterns. A study published by Northeastern University in October 2021 found that 95 percent of the top 240 Android apps employed deceptive patterns. Another international study published in 2019 discovered that out of 5,000 privacy notifications sent out by a slew of companies across Europe, more than half used dark patterns. Furthermore, a large-scale study analyzing ~53K product pages from ~11K shopping websites discovered 1,818 instances of dark patterns, which together represent 15 types of dark patterns.

These statistics underscore the urgency of addressing this issue. UX professionals have a significant role to play in this regard. They can advocate for users and ensure that user interface design follows the highest ethical standards and intent. They can also educate non-designers about the ramifications of using dark patterns, which may include costly legal issues for an organization.


History of Dark Patterns

The term "dark patterns" was coined by Harry Brignull in 2010. Dark patterns refer to deceptive design elements intentionally created to manipulate users into taking actions they might not have otherwise chosen. The goal is often to boost engagement, increase conversion rates, or extract more data from users.

The prevalence of dark patterns can be traced back to the early days of the internet, but their use has become more sophisticated as technology has advanced. In the pursuit of profits, some companies have resorted to unethical tactics, leading to a negative impact on user trust and satisfaction.


Design is a reflection of our values; let's make sure ours reflect honesty and respect for the user.

Types of Dark Patterns

There are several types of dark patterns identified by experts in the field:

  1. False Urgency: Creates a sense of urgency or scarcity to pressure consumers into making a purchase or taking an action.

  2. Basket Sneaking: Dark patterns are used to add additional products or services to the shopping cart without the user’s consent.

  3. Confirm Shaming: Uses guilt to make consumers adhere; criticizes or attacks consumers for not conforming to a particular belief or viewpoint.

  4. Forced Action: Pushes consumers into taking an action they may not want to take, such as signing up for a service in order to access content.

  5. Nagging: Persistent criticism, complaints, and requests for action.

  6. Subscription traps: Easy to sign up for a service but difficult to quit or cancel; option is hidden or requires multiple steps.

  7. Bait & Switch: Advertising a certain product/service but delivering another, often of lower quality.

  8. Hidden costs: Hiding additional costs until consumers are already committed to making a purchase.

  9. Disguised ads: Designed to look like content, such as news articles or user-generated content.

Examples of Dark Patterns

Here are some examples of dark patterns:

  • Misdirection: This is where the website design nudges users towards a more expensive option and distracts them from the standard option. For instance, Delta uses a red button to nudge checking-in users towards an upgrade.

  • Checkbox treachery: This involves obfuscatory checkboxes, which are probably the most famous and most common examples of dark patterns. These are opt-in or opt-out checkboxes and accompanying spiel that businesses use to give customers notional control over how their contact data is used.


Ethical Practices to Avoid Dark Patterns

To avoid dark patterns, companies should prioritize transparency, user control, and ethical design practices, fostering positive user experiences and long-term customer loyalty. Here are some crucial techniques to avoid dark patterns in UX:

  1. Introduce stringent design practice protocols: This includes setting up guidelines that discourage the use of dark patterns and encourage responsible design practices.

  2. Enhance the preference for user experience: Prioritize the needs and expectations of the users over business goals.

  3. Provide tremendous favor on user interests: Make sure that the design decisions align with the interests of the users.

  4. Follow ethical UX design processes: This includes being transparent about data collection and usage, and respecting user privacy.

  5. Conduct extensive research on user expectations: Understand the needs and expectations of the users to create designs that are user-friendly and ethical.


Dark patterns may cast a temporary shadow, but ethical design creates a lasting legacy of trust.

Role of UX in Avoiding Dark Patterns

User Experience (UX) plays a crucial role in avoiding dark patterns. UX designers must avoid using dark patterns in their designs and instead prioritize transparency, honesty, and ethical practices. By doing so, designers can build user trust, improve user satisfaction and loyalty, and ultimately drive business growth and success.

UX professionals can contribute significantly to this process. They can advocate for users and ensure that user interface design follows the highest ethical standards and intent. They can also educate non-designers about the ramifications of using dark patterns, which may include costly legal issues for an organization.


UX Maturity

User Experience Maturity (or UX Maturity) measures how well a company designs, builds, and delivers experiences to users that meet their needs. It describes a journey from uncommitted to committed UX practice, i.e., from a fundamental understanding of UX principles to advanced UX expertise in the organization. The level of UX maturity directly impacts the overall user satisfaction, customer loyalty, and ultimately, the success and competitiveness of the organization.


A higher level of UX maturity can help solve dark pattern issues ethically. Companies with a high level of UX maturity are more likely to prioritize user needs and ethical practices, leading to a reduction in the use of dark patterns.


The path to great design is paved with the bricks of honesty, empathy, and transparency.

Conclusion

Dark patterns are a pressing issue in the digital world today. While they may lead to short-term gains for businesses, they erode user trust and can lead to long-term losses. It’s crucial for companies to prioritize ethical UX practices and strive to increase their UX maturity. By doing so, they can ensure a positive user experience, build customer loyalty, and drive sustainable business growth.

Recent studies have shed light on the prevalence of dark patterns. A study published by Northeastern University in October 2021 found that 95 percent of the top 240 Android apps employed deceptive patterns. Another international study published in 2019 discovered that out of 5,000 privacy notifications sent out by a slew of companies across Europe, more than half used dark patterns. Furthermore, a large-scale study analyzing ~53K product pages from ~11K shopping websites discovered 1,818 instances of dark patterns, which together represent 15 types of dark patterns.

These statistics underscore the urgency of addressing this issue. UX professionals have a significant role to play in this regard. They can advocate for users and ensure that user interface design follows the highest ethical standards and intent. They can also educate non-designers about the ramifications of using dark patterns, which may include costly legal issues for an organization.

In conclusion, the fight against dark patterns is a collective responsibility that requires the commitment of all stakeholders in the digital space. By prioritizing ethical UX practices and increasing UX maturity, we can create a digital world that respects user autonomy and fosters trust. This is not just an ethical imperative but also a strategic move that can drive sustainable business growth. Let’s make the digital world a better place, one user experience at a time.



Article by Mr.Tushar Deshmukh, CEO & Founder UXExpert, Dir. UXUITraining Lab Pvt. Ltd. other services - UXResearch, UXUIHiring, UXTalks, UXTools


UXExpert - is India's top 10 User Experience Service Provider.

UXUITraining Lab Pvt. Ltd. is India's top mentoring and training provider for User Experience

UXTalks Interviews, talk shows, events Live talk show where we discuss about Design




16 views0 comments
bottom of page